Blog Archive

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Geological Society: Acidifying oceans spell marine biological meltdown “by end of century” -- Co-author: "Unless we curb carbon emissions we risk mass extinctions, degrading coastal waters and encouraging outbreaks of toxic jellyfish and algae"


Co-author: "Unless we curb carbon emissions we risk mass extinctions, degrading coastal waters and encouraging outbreaks of toxic jellyfish and algae."



by Joseph Romm, August 31, 2010
A unique ‘natural laboratory’ in the Mediterranean Sea is revealing the effects of rising carbon dioxide levels on life in the oceans. The results show a bleak future for marine life as ocean acidity rises, and suggest that similar lowering of ocean pH levels may have been responsible for massive extinctions in the past.
That’s the opening (and headline) of a news release from the Geological Society of London.  The new study is “Modern seawater acidification: the response of foraminifera to high-CO2conditions in the Mediterranean Sea” (subs. reqd.) in the latest Journal of the Geological Society.


For background on ocean acidification, see Nature Geoscience: Oceans are acidifying 10 times faster today than 55 million years ago when a mass extinction of marine species occurred.

The study identified a tipping point at “mean pH 7.8":

The scientists, from the University of Plymouth and the University of Santa Catarina, Brazil, studied a single celled organisms called Foraminifera around volcanic carbon dioxide vents off Naples in Italy. The study, published in the September issue of the Journal of the Geological Society, found that increasing CO2 levels caused foram diversity to fall from 24 species to only 4. 
‘Previous studies have shown a reduction in diversity of 30%, but this is even bigger for forams,’ said Dr Jason Hall-Spencer, one of the study’s co-authors. ‘A tipping point occurs at mean pH 7.8. This is the pH level predicted for the end of this century.
The figure below [not from the study] shows the pH trend vs. the CO2 trend around “Station ALOHA, the HOT deep-water station (22 45′ N, 158 W), located about 100 km north of Oahu, Hawaii:
http://cmore.soest.hawaii.edu/images/aloha_curve_dave267a.gif
Uhh, pH 7.8 — here we come.

I would note that this study, based as it on a natural laboratory, doesn’t even include the behind impact of rising ocean temperatures with rising acidification.  For an analysis of what that could mean, see 2009 Nature Geoscience study concludes ocean dead zones “devoid of fish and seafood” are poised to expand and “remain for thousands of years.”

Back to the news release:
Rising carbon dioxide levels acidify the ocean, which has a particularly devastating effect on organisms that have calcium carbonate shells, like Foraminifera. 
‘Forams are well preserved in the fossil record, which is why we chose to study them,’ says Dr Hall-Spencer. ‘We knew the results were likely to show a decline in foram diversity but we weren’t expecting such a seismic shift.’ 
Forams record past events in the geological record – in particular, the effect of the Palaeocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM), a period of massive carbon release and rapid warming, 55 million years ago, accompanied by extinctions in marine life. It is also thought to have seen a period of ocean acidification. 
‘That was a period when massive changes in marine ecology happened,’ says Dr Hall-Spencer. ‘Our natural laboratory provides a glimpse into the future of our oceans.’ 
‘These are the first CO2 vents to be used to study ocean acidification. They allow us to observe how ecosystems react to changes in ocean acidity. We can see for our own eyes what increasing CO2 levels do to marine communities.’ 
‘At a mean pH level of 7.8, calcified organisms begin to disappear, and non calcifying ones take over. We are headed towards that being the case in this century. The big concern for me is that unless we curb carbon emissions we risk mass extinctions, degrading coastal waters and encouraging outbreaks of toxic jellyfish and algae.’
It is self-destructive for the nation and world not to begin rapid and sharp CO2 reductions.

Related posts:
Link:  http://climateprogress.org/2010/08/31/geological-society-acid-ocean-marine-lif/

Modern seawater acidification: the response of foraminifera to high-CO2 conditions in the Mediterranean Sea, JGS 167 (2010), B. B. Dias, M. B. Hart, C. W. Smart & J. M. Hall-Spencer

Journal of the Geological Society (September 2010), 167(5): 843-846; DOI: 10.1144/0016-76492010-050

Modern seawater acidification: the response of foraminifera to high-CO2 conditions in the Mediterranean Sea


B. B. Dias1M. B. Hart2,*C. W. Smart2 and J. M. Hall-Spencer3


1 Laboratório de Oceanografia Costeira, Departamento de Geociências, CFH Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Florianopólis, SC 88040-900, Brazil
2 School of Geography, Earth & Environmental Sciences, University of Plymouth, Drake Circus, Plymouth PL4 8AA, UK
3 School of Marine Science & Engineering, University of Plymouth, Drake Circus, Plymouth PL4 8AA, UK

Abstract

The seas around the island of Ischia (Italy) have a lowered pH as a result of volcanic gas vents that emit carbon dioxide from the sea floor at ambient seawater temperatures. These areas of acidified seawater provide natural laboratories in which to study the long-term biological response to rising CO2 levels. Benthic foraminifera (single-celled protists) are particularly interesting as they have short life histories, are environmentally sensitive and have an excellent fossil record. Here, we examine changes in foraminiferal assemblages along pH gradients at CO2 vents on the coast of Ischia and show that the foraminiferal distribution, diversity and nature of the fauna change markedly in the living assemblages as pH decreases.



*Correspondence e-mail: mhart@plymouth.ac.uk


Link:  http://jgs.geoscienceworld.org/cgi/content/abstract/167/5/843

August 2010 posts

August 2010 posts


  • Earth may be too hot for humans by 2300

  • Wells Fargo, Credit Suisse, Rabobank, Morgan Stanl...

  • Peter Ditlevsen: Sudden climate change may be due ...

  • Koch Brothers and Big Coal foiled again! Judge th...

  • AP: A Mongolian cabinet’s photo op in the scorched...

  • Wheat exports to China triple in deregulated marke...

  • The myth of the climate science gravy train: Scien...

  • Is Fracking Even Worse Than Drilling? by William F...

  • Attribution of Climate-Related Events -- scientist...

  • Fracking and the Environment: Natural Gas Drilling...

  • More major U.S. corporations join Forest Ethics in...

  • William M. Connolley on the Liu and Curry paper: "...

  • Eli Rabett on Judith Curry's latest bit of sloppin...

  • Frank Rich: "The Billionaires Bankrolling the Tea ...

  • Joe Romm on Andy Revkin's worst Dot Earth post eve...

  • Steve Easterbrook has his say on Andrew Revkin's l...

  • TED.com: Lee Hotz reports on the WAIS Divide ice c...

  • Solomon Hsiang, Fight Entropy blog, A new mechanis...

  • Wieslaw Maslowski's Arctic sea ice volume decline ...

  • John Shimkus (R-IL) vs. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) --...

  • Help Pakistan: Donate for HDF flood appeal in Paki...

  • Models show Arctic sea ice nearly disappearing in ...

  • Chris Mooney: Arctic Ice -- Less Than Meets The E...

  • Heidi Cullen on The Colbert Report discusses her b...

  • NOAA's NSIDC Arctic Report, August 17, 2010

  • The Northwest and Northeast Passages are open. Nor...

  • Ocean acidification threatens entire marine food c...

  • Lee Fang: Charles And David Koch Exposed For Insi...

  • Join 10:10 and do something positive for the plane...

  • Huge chunk of 3000-5000 year old ice shelf breaks ...

  • Koch Industries spends 48 million dollars in fundi...

  • Northwest and Northeast Passages are now really, r...

  • Koch dirty-energy millions used to manipulate the ...

  • Upper-ocean-to-atmosphere radiocarbon offsets impl...

  • Elisabeth Sikes: A 'Great Fizz' of Carbon Dioxide ...

  • Tom Guilderson: results suggest that there was a r...

  • KPMG review finds IPCC chief Pachauri innocent of ...

  • Pakistan’s Climate Change Floods, Seen From Above

  • Rachel Maddow tells all on the Koch brothers of Ko...

  • Koch family and psychological problems caused by n...

  • Increasing intensity of El Niño in the central-equ...

  • Rachel Maddow reports on David Koch's lies about h...

  • Koch Brothers Called Out for Waging War Against Ob...

  • NASA/NOAA Study Finds El Niños are Growing Stronge...

  • Activist by James Hansen -- Stabilizing climate is...

  • Larry Gibson, Jim Hansen and Ken Hechler --These a...

  • Greenpeace: Koch Industries Secretly Funding the C...

  • Call for Boycott of Koch Industries' Georgia Pacif...

  • Koch family of Koch Industries spends $15 million ...

  • J. C. Moore, S. Jevrejeva & A. Grinsted, PNAS (201...

  • J. C. Moore, S. Jevrejeva & A. Grinsted: Geoengine...

  • "James Hansen et al. hit a Climate Home Run -- in ...

  • Jane Mayer, The NewYorker: The billionaire Koch b...

  • Temperatures and cyclones strongly associated with...

  • Pakistan flood: many more will die unless more aid...

  • Medieval Warm Period: rhetoric vs science by Rober...

  • Accelerated warming of the Southern Ocean and its ...

  • J. Inoue et al., A polar low embedded in a blockin...

  • NOAA's Bill Lehr says three-quarters of the oil th...

  • Climate Denial Machine lackey Andrew Montford set ...

  • UVA Students, Faculty and Alumni To Protest Ken Cu...

  • On the immorality of climate change denial and jou...

  • Arthur Smith on Keith Kloor's obsessive misreprese...

  • DeepClimate eviscerates McShane and Wyner 2010

  • Drought-induced reduction in global terrestrial ne...

  • Earth's global plant yields decline due to increas...

  • Seth Borenstein, AP: Adaptation means investments ...

  • NASA JPL Radar images of Greenland glaciers

  • Swiss-Re: Caribbean Storm Damage Costs May Rise 50...

  • Humboldt Glacier grounding line

  • ERS radar mosaic and velocity maps of northern Gre...

  • Jason Box: Petermann not the only major ‘loser’ i...

  • 3600 ft deep, 20 mile oil plume from the Deepwater...

  • Jeff Masters: Massive 926 mb extratropical storm g...

  • Tracking hydrocarbon plume transport and biodegrad...

  • Scientists at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institu...

  • Why Oil Billionaire David Koch Is Secretly Funding...

  • Groups file brief supporting U.Va. in case against...

  • Gore calls for major protests on climate change in...

  • More than two dozen local chambers of commerce in ...

  • Massive coral die-off seen in 93 °F waters. Area o...

  • Richard Black, BBC: Delivering biochar's triple w...

  • Jason Box: Of Greenland's 30 widest glaciers, the ...

  • Heidi Cullen, Daily Beast: The Hottest Summer Eve...

  • Heidi Cullen: The Weather of the Future -- Heat W...

  • Help Pakistan

  • Tamino's Open Mind: "Red Hot" -- The Russian Heat...

  • Pakistan Flood photos on CNN online

  • The Curious Case of the Hockey Stick that didn’t d...

  • Moscow, Through a Cloud of Smoke by Vera Pavlova

  • The "CO2 is plant food" Crock by Peter Sinclair

  • Gavin Schmidt, Patrick Michaels, Jeffrey Sachs int...

  • Justin Gillis, NYT: In Weather Chaos, a Case for G...

  • Scientists Need Attitude! -- The Mass Psychology o...

  • Peter H. Gleick: Global Weirding: Naming Climate ...

  • Jeff Masters: Causes of the Russian heat wave and ...

  • Spontaneous transition to superrotation in warm cl...

  • Observations of SST, heat flux and North Atlantic ...

  • James Hansen: What Global Warming Looks Like . . ....

  • Gavin Schmidt of Real Climate on PBS's "Need to Kn...

  • Tom Tomorrow, Salon: Reality -- Who needs it!

  • Tom Toles: Fire Escapism

  • John Cook, Skeptical Science: NASA-GISS: July 201...

  • Barry Bickmore, RealClimate: Monckton Makes It Up...

  • Green machine: Don't burn plant waste, bury it -- ...

  • Monckton Chronicles or More Moncktongate or the Lo...

  • Richard Alley: Greenland ice sheet faces 'tipping...

  • The crack in the roof of the world: 'Yes, global w...

  • John Collins Rudolf, Green Inc.: Has a warming Rus...

  • Jeff Masters: July SSTs in the tropical Atlantic ...

  • Jeff Masters and Russian Meteorological Center: “T...

  • Bob Altemeyer's "The Authoritarians" updated editi...

  • Eli Rabett's Chris Monckton Limerick Contest

  • Bjorn Lomborg's copious errors!!!

  • Snowcone Greenland's Jakobhavn's Isbrae breaking u...

  • Jeff Masters: The Great Russian Heat Wave of 2010

  • Joseph Romm: Global boiling fuels disasters in nuc...

  • Jakobshavn Isbrae, August 5, 2010

  • Petermann Glacier loses the end of its tongue, Aug...

  • Chrissy Pissy Monckton found out with pants down. ...

  • Monckton NOT A MEMBER OF THE HOUSE OF LORDS! What...

  • George Shultz: There’s a climate problem connected...

  • Michael Mann slandered again by Clive Crook of the...

  • Enbridge Oil Disaster: Tar sands piped from Canada...

  • Did NASA (under the Cheney/Bush regime) mislead th...

  • Seth Borenstein, AP: US top scientists urge coal,...

  • Ok, so are we gonna call the Northwest Passage ope...

  • Post-modern post-normalism disease strikes Virgini...

  • Hundreds of new wildfires break out in Russia

  • A dark ideology is driving those who deny climate ...

  • Joseph Romm: Lost in translation: In a Brazilian ...